I’m going to start this thread as a thought-provoking piece, I’m not criticizing what anyone does with their money by posting it, I’m not trying to elevate this line of thinking, none of that. Not trying to start a flame war. I posted a thread like this years ago in the old community, and got dumped on, and if it happens again I’m just going to delete it because who needs that? If this thread offends you… stop reading it.
But here’s the thing… simple, slow (monthly, not day-trading) trading methods like the 10-month moving average method can save your bacon during bear markets, and guess what, the 10-month moving average threw a sell signal on Friday, April 29. Disclosure… I did sell most of my stocks on Monday May 2, I will keep a few because I think they are undervalued diamonds in the rough.
Reading list:
A Quantitative Approach to Tactical Asset Allocation by Meb Faber
Advisor Perspectives moving average tracking page, which has some great charts showing past signals, including some going back to The Great Depression
What Is the 200-Day Simple Moving Average? (investopedia.com) {200 trading days is about 10 months}
A live simulator showing Vanguard VFINX and the 10-month moving average method versus buy-and-hold VFINX. VFINX is an old S&P500 mutual fund.
The point is not to get more returns, but avoid withering drawdowns and sequence of returns risk. Unfortunately, human nature being what it is, this is terribly hard to stick with during uptrends, because you get “fire drills” which sap your returns, and then you feel badly when your friends are making more than you in Gamestock and Crypto, and you think, “Argh, why am I bothering with TAA on the S&P500 index, I should YOLO!!!”
Then the end of the bull market comes. Are we there? I don’t know. I just follow my rule.
Rule: compute on the last trading day of the month the 10-month moving average of the S&P500. If stock prices close above it, hold stocks. If they close below it, sell stocks. You can apply this rule to 0%-100% of your portfolio. It’s your money, make your own decisions.
Wall Street does not buy-and-hold, but they tell retail investors to buy-and-hold. “Where are the customer’s yachts?”