Buying tires from Costco

I agree that Costco has great prices and good service. However, I have a Subaru, and they will not rotate my tires, as they say that Subaru has some sort of faulty stem that breaks sometimes when removing the tires. I took the car to a car repair shop. They verified that but said if the rotation is done with care that there is no problem. Costco does it very quickly and puts too much strain on that stem (or whatever…I am not a car person). This situation tends to make the free rotation offer from Costco be meaningless if you have a Subaru. Tires are still a good buy, but you can’t get them rotated if you have a Subaru.

1 Like

I bought tires from Costco on 8/09/25, spending $628. Mileage at that time 34,309. I experienced a TPMS warning, took my car in on 10/26/26 after driving only 5,000 miles was told one failed and two showing low battery and one was OK. To replace the failed one would be $60.00. They recommended replacing all as “they probably would fail also” to the tune of $233.!!! They said 7 year warranty did not cover the sensors they installed. I felt “cornered” into purchasing all. Not so inexpensive after all at Costco.

Thanks for the info on the TPMS, if it was a total price of like $233 for all 5 tires, spare included I would say that was a great deal. I need to keep that in mind next time they go out.

That sounds frustrating, especially after only 5,000 miles. It might be worth asking another tyre shop for a second opinion on the sensors before replacing all of them, as they can often be checked one by one. Keeping the receipt and the warranty wording handy can also help if you query the charge with Costco.

The one-by-one check is the part that stands out to me. If three sensors were already low at 5,000 miles, that sounds more like a batch or install issue than normal wear, so I would ask for the sensor brand and part numbers before paying for all four. Also worth confirming whether the $233 covers programming and labor or just parts. In Orlando the heat does shorten sensor battery life, but not that fast. Holding the receipt and warranty wording is solid advice.